“Pretty but dull, with unconvincing turns from Zeta-Jones and Pearce. If you want a period magician movie, seek out The Prestige or The Illusionist instead.”
Any magic is instantly dispelled by the dead hand of a tirelessly pouting Zeta-Jones, whose slap boasts more layers than her talent.
D
Derek Malcolm
RTLondon Evening StandardAug 8, 2008
It's all a touch undercooked and dull.
A
Anthony Quinn
RTIndependent (UK)Aug 8, 2008
It's a movie that seems to have been lavished with care and performed with gusto, yet its tale of fakery sounds its own knell: there's not a believable moment in it.
B
Brian Eggert
RTDeep Focus ReviewMar 7, 2024
Immersed in beautifully atmospheric location photography by cinematographer Haris Zambarloukos, shooting in and around original Scottish architecture, the film’s presentation is stunning.