Director Yates knows how to shape even the sketchiest scenario, and if John and Mary is no deeper than an eggshell, it is every bit as functionally designed.
V
Variety Staff
RTVarietyJul 26, 2007
The entire charade is smoothly contrived.
G
Geoff Andrew
RTTime OutJun 24, 2006
Hoffman and Farrow awake to each other in a New York bed and interminably worry, via chat, fantasy, flashback and some trendy cultural reference, whether they should do it again.
L
Larry Zolf
RTMaclean's MagazineJun 15, 2022
The problem with John and Mary is that in this case the fruits of sin make for a rotten film.